Gary Lee Setzer thumbnail

Gary Lee Setzer

April 25, 1948 - June 30, 2019

Gary Lee Setzer, 71, died on Sunday, June 30, 2019.

He was born in Bellaire, Ohio, where he was raised in a house built by his father, Melvin Paul Setzer. He spent his last years in that same home. He was preceded in death by his father, and his mother, Marcelyn L. Setzer.

Gary will be remembered for his amiable presence. Known for his charismatic and cavalier sense of humor, he was always the funniest person in the room. He attended Bellaire High School, graduating in 1966. He loved music enthusiastically and was a proficient self-taught banjo player. He enjoyed movies and television, playing poker, spicy food and gardening in his backyard.

He owned and operated Setzer’s Meat Market in Shadyside, Ohio, with his former wife, Jacqueline Setzer, until 1986. Later, Gary was a meat cutter for Kroger, retiring from the Bellaire Kroger in 2011. After retirement, he volunteered as a bartender at the Neffs Rod & Gun Club.

He will be greatly missed by his family and friends, including his siblings, Paul Setzer (Cheryl Setzer), Rebecca Stead and Patricia Phillips; his children, Michele Setzer (Michael Kaminsky) and Gary Lee Setzer Jr. (Angela Zielinski); his three grandchildren, Grayson Kaminsky, Matthew Kaminsky and Penelope Simon Setzer; his nieces and nephews, Michael Paul Setzer, Marci Muckleroy, Todd Phillips Jr. and Tristan Cassidy; and his eight great-nieces and nephews.

A private memorial service for the family will be held at West Virginia University in the following months and a public reception for family and friends will be announced at that time.

In lieu of flowers, please make donations to the MetroHealth Brain Center – who provided a light for Gary in his most trying of

Life Event Timeline

Help tell the story of Gary by contributing to the Life Event Timeline. Upload the photo of an event...

Post an Event

Leave a Condolence

View All Condolences Post a Condolence

What our families say...

The fact Bauknecht-Altmeyers has taken care of so many family members. They truly treat you like family.


A Session ID is required to purchase jewelry with your loved one's fingerprint, click here to continue. If you do not have an ID, click here to contact us to get your Session ID.